Back to blogs

Video or paper? What the research says about exercise instruction

By Kinmo teamPublished on 7 min

Do you send a home exercise out on paper, with photos, or on video? There is more research on this than you might expect, and it keeps pointing the same way: with video, people perform an exercise more accurately than from a printout, and about as well as after instruction from a physical therapist. Below are the studies, what they actually measured, and where video falls short.

What goes wrong with a printout

In a randomized study in Physical Therapy, Reo and Mercer (2004) taught 40 healthy adults five shoulder exercises in one of four ways: demonstrated live, on a video showing errors and corrections, on an error-free video, or from a printed handout alone. Performance was measured immediately after instruction and again a day later.

The handout group performed the exercises less accurately and made more than twice as many errors in total as the live and video groups did on average.

That is not hard to explain. Starting position, repetitions and target muscle are easy to put on paper. How the movement runs from start to finish is much harder.

Video holds its own against live instruction

In the same study there was no difference between the live group and the two video groups, either immediately or a day later.

Berkoff et al. (2016) compared the two head to head. 58 healthy participants learned four shoulder exercises: 30 got a video showing correct technique alongside common mistakes, 28 got half an hour of instruction from a physical therapist plus a handout. After a week of practice at home, their performance was filmed and scored. The video group scored 13.66, the PT group 13.46 (p = 0.64): no difference.

For teaching correct technique, then, a good video does as well as in-clinic instruction. One caveat: both studies used healthy adults, small groups and a follow-up of one day to one week.

Photos or video

A handout with photos is the obvious middle ground. Weeks et al. (2002) compared video with still photographs in 20 healthy participants learning simple and more complex exercises. The video group performed the exercises better, both while learning and on the retention test a day later. The video group also reported being more motivated to exercise at home and more confident they were doing it correctly. Every participant preferred video.

That second finding matters because self-efficacy and self-motivation were among the factors that most clearly predicted adherence to home-based programs in a systematic review (Essery et al., 2017). Weeks did not measure adherence itself, so the link is indirect.

What video does not fix

Accuracy can drift. Rasmussen et al. (2013) followed 76 caregivers of children with neonatal brachial plexus palsy. They exercised at home with an instruction DVD after a single demonstration by an occupational therapist. Over twelve months, accuracy held at most joints, but at the shoulder it fell from 98.9 percent to 88.3 percent at the first check, around three months in. At the elbow it went from 100 to 96.6 percent. The authors conclude that these exercises need more frequent review. A video does not replace that check.

Duration and contact matter. Rihova et al. (2024) pooled 26 studies with 1,292 participants over 65 who exercised at home with video. Mean retention was 91.1 percent and session attendance 85.0 percent. Longer sessions went with lower attendance: going from under 20 to over 60 minutes was associated with an estimated 24 percentage points less. Programs without live contact with a coach (DVD or pre-recorded web video) had lower attendance than live online sessions, by an estimated 11 percentage points. These were exercise programs for older adults, not individual home programs after treatment, but the direction is clear: a recorded video does not replace contact with you.

What to take from this for your own videos

  • Show the movement, not only the end position. In Weeks, video beat photos.
  • Showing mistakes is fine, but not required. Berkoff used a video with common errors. In Reo and Mercer, such a video did as well as an error-free one.
  • Keep the program manageable. In Rihova's meta-analysis, longer sessions went with lower attendance.
  • Schedule a check. In Rasmussen, accuracy dropped mainly for shoulder and elbow exercises.

Your own video on the exercise

None of these studies tested whether a video of your own physical therapist works better than a professionally produced video of the same exercise. What all three trials did test was a video of exactly the exercises the participant had to learn. A video showing a slightly different variant from the one you prescribe is not the same thing.

That is why Kinmo makes it easy to put your own recording on an exercise. Every exercise has a slot for a photo and a video. The library is a base to start from; you can add your own video in three ways:

Exercises from your website, YouTube, Word, PDF, your laptop or your phone camera come together in Kinmo; Instagram is coming soon

  • Film with your phone. At your computer, you scan a QR code and your phone takes over. On a phone or tablet, the camera opens directly. You don't need to log in on the phone.
  • Upload a file you already have, up to 200 MB and three minutes.
  • Paste a direct link to a video file. A YouTube or Vimeo link won't play for the patient; a YouTube playlist can be imported instead.

Film it once and reuse it with every patient who has the same complaint. Start with the exercises you prescribe most.

Conclusion

Three small trials between 2002 and 2016, all in healthy adults, reach the same result: with video, people perform an exercise more accurately than from paper or photos, and about as well as after instruction from a physical therapist. Research with longer follow-up shows that accuracy can drift after a few months and that contact with a coach raises attendance. A video does not make the follow-up check unnecessary.

Every study in this piece is summarized on our research page, alongside the rest of the literature on home exercise programs. You can go straight to Reo & Mercer, Weeks and Berkoff.


Sources

  • Reo, J.A. & Mercer, V.S. (2004). Effects of live, videotaped, or written instruction on learning an upper-extremity exercise program. Physical Therapy, 84(7), 622-633. PMID 15225081
  • Weeks, D.L., Brubaker, J., Byrt, J., Davis, M., Hamann, L. & Reagan, J. (2002). Videotape instruction versus illustrations for influencing quality of performance, motivation, and confidence to perform simple and complex exercises in healthy subjects. Physiotherapy Theory and Practice, 18(2), 65-73. DOI 10.1080/09593980290058454
  • Berkoff, D.J. et al. (2016). Corrected error video versus a physical therapist instructed home exercise program: accuracy of performing therapeutic shoulder exercises. International Journal of Sports Physical Therapy, 11(5), 757-764. PMID 27757288
  • Rasmussen, L., Justice, D., Chang, K.W., Nelson, V.S. & Yang, L.J. (2013). Home exercise DVD promotes exercise accuracy by caregivers of children and adolescents with brachial plexus palsy. PM&R, 5(11), 924-930. PMID 23770351
  • Rihova, M. et al. (2024). Adherence and Retention Rates to Home-Based Video Exercise Programs in Older Adults: Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. Telemedicine and e-Health, 30(11), 2649-2661. PMID 39072676
  • Essery, R., Geraghty, A.W., Kirby, S. & Yardley, L. (2017). Predictors of adherence to home-based physical therapies: a systematic review. Disability and Rehabilitation, 39(6), 519-534. PMID 27097761

Kinmo builds the exercise program: in your clinic's look, as a link to your patient.

Every plan starts free: 30 days, up to 100 treatment episodes. No payment details, and it ends by itself.